Kim Gentes

Studying is different than experiencing. One normally studies to gain knowledge, while experience leads to something slightly different- understanding. Understanding is the signature of Thomas Cahill's now iconic book "How The Irish Saved Civilization". One enters into it hoping to learn something, but one leaves it with understanding. This happens because Cahill becomes not only a wordsmithing instructor in our class on the ancient world, but an articulate story-teller of the larger narrative of western civilization.

Beginning with the 5th century (and weaving back and forth through time as necessary), Cahill explores the foundations of the fall of the Roman Empire, including the sentiment and arrogance of a Roman leadership, fat from centuries of literal world-wide conquest. From there, we learn the common practice of slavery (through banditry and outright capture) that was rife through Europe. This quickly leads to an introduction to the Irish and their war parties that scourged the coast of Britain, capturing thousands of slaves for its tribal societies back on Ireland. Briefly, we hear of one such slave that was brought from "civilized" Roman camped Briton to the wiles of Irish clans- the young Patricius. Of course, he will become a central player in this story, but not yet.

The book then detours back to continental Europe and delves extensively into the foundations of Christian apologetic thinker and literary giant Augustine of Hippo. After a few foundational discussions on his Greek influence via Plato and Socrates, we are taken on a brief survey of the Greek classical writers Homer, Virgil and Cicero. Cahill does all this seeming meandering to establish one thing- a lens (via Augustine) through which he can paint his picture of the ancient world. Once he thinks you have gotten this, the book moves on to explain the destruction of the Roman empire. He explains how wave after wave of barbarian tribes ransacked Rome (and its power centers) not only of its gold, grain and able-bodied workers, but washed its culture, science and literacy into oblivion. Cahill puts it poignantly:

As Roman culture died out and was replaced by vibrant new barbarian growths, people forgot many things—how to read, how to think, how to build magnificently...[1]

But he quickly points out that amidst this destructive scene, one thing did stand- the church:

There was, moreover, one office that survived intact from the classical to the medieval polis: the office of Catholic bishop.[2]

Cahill's Europe is taking shape, and we see that while governments were failing, the religious institution of the Catholic church was maintaining a sense of sovereignty, and almost untouchable preeminence. At this point, the book turns back to Ireland and we get a full chapter of history on the Celts- ranging back to 300-500 BC and brought forward through recitation of their literature (mostly extensive quotes from the Tain) and some wide assortment of lore and nuance to the uniquely Irish persona.

By the time we are caught up on the Irish story, we are reintroduced to Patricius, who by now has been explained as the slave who eventually escaped his Irish captors. In a tremendous revelation from God, he re-envisions his life as a missionary to the homeland of his former captives. He returns to Ireland and almost single-handedly converts the entire country (made up of several tribal "kingdoms") to Christianity. The most profound implication of this, for Cahill, becomes the marked change of the Irish (and its Patrician monks in particular) from lives of barbarism to cultured thinkers, readers, and most of all, scribes.

Cahill is clear that Christianity received the Irish (who never gave up their unique historical, cultural and psychological imprint) through the vehicle of Patrick, and in doing so retained its unique identity as Irish. But it became, at just the right time, the center for collection, reclamation and copy of nearly all western classical literature, whether it be religious, cultural or scientific. The Irish monasteries became the information databases of western civilization, at a time when the Roman world was being decimated by the constant infusion of military campaigns from the previously pummelled peoples of neighboring states. Patrick gave Christianity and classical literacy to the Irish, and Irish in turn, kept it for safe-keeping until the destruction of the Roman world was complete. Once it was, according to Cahill, the Irish monasteries and its monks flooded the British, Gaulish and continental coasts of Europe to bring that literature back to the western world.

Cahill's work is undeniably impressive. Both as historical comprehension (which the rest of us can appreciate and understand without the lifetime of historical research it would require), and as narrative art, "How The Irish Save Civilization" is a monumentally riveting book. It is story, history, and yarn, all wrapped well into a brilliant thesis.

For certain, Cahill pontificates on his personal soapbox throughout, and as he wraps up, his book. A fair warning is also given to Cahill's seeming supposition that he must use the F-word at least once in each of his books, which he complies with (though in high style, if you can imagine) here.  Like, his book "Mysteries of the Middle Ages", Cahill has a couple of axes to grind and he isn't shy about brandishing his blade when the right sharpening stone comes along. However, this should not deter any reader from reading his exceptional insights. He takes the time to point out injustice, conflict and modern problems that could well learn from the lessons of antiquity pointed out by his book. These brief, though regular, interjections in the story are easy to spot and easy to agree with (or not, should the reader dissent).

The trail that the book weaves through history and your mind feels a bit mythical, while at the same time far more human than I have ever heard from any stories of antiquity I've read elsewhere. It's a gorgeous balance. One doesn't leave this book without feeling the impact of Cahill's intention to both teach history and hope the present to be changed by it.

A marvelous book.

Product Link on Amazon: How the Irish Saved Civilization

Review by
Kim Gentes

[1]Thomas Cahill, "How The Irish Saved Civilization", (New York, NY: Anchor Books 1995), Pg 60
[2]Ibid., Pg 60