Not so true. Not much grit.
| Overall Grade: | C |
| Story: | B- |
| Acting: | C |
| Direction: | C- |
| Visuals: | B- |
Summary: I have to admit, I went to this film because it was directed by the Coen brothers. Their ability to take a story and turn its perspective upside down without ruining it is near legendary. And while they certainly did take a seeming classic story and spin its viewpoint, the result is a placid, ineffectual, yarn with little drama and misuse of a star-studded cast.
The Coens had help in killing the life of this film, but not from Hailee Steinfeld. Hailee plays Mattie Ross, a 14 year old girl who is left to deal with her murdered father's affairs. She takes it upon herself to hire two men to track down her father's killer and joins them in the pursuit. Her acting is crisp and well set for the role and story. It could be argued that she overplays the capabilities of a 14 year old, but that seems to be written into the story and not a misrepresentation in her acting.
Jeffe Bridges also does a reasonable job as the drunken, hard-nosed US Marshal, Rooster Cogburn. Flashes of intensity in his character save the film from absolute boredom. Matt Damon is ill-cast as the lucid, weakling Texas Ranger, LaBoeuf. He provides a sympathetic, but nearly ineffectual character that neither fits Damon's intense style or helps the film. Likewise, James Brolen's character is less than what you hope for as well. Neutered by a subjugated role to the "Lucky Ned Pepper" character, Brolen ends up in 2 strange and almost discardable scenes. All this leaves you thinking- "that's the villain?" The real antagonist ends up being the "Lucky Ned Pepper" character, whose namesake is ironically similar to the actor, Barry Pepper, who plays him. Pepper (actor and character) is the only one who seems to take the film as a serious western. If you're looking for "grit", Pepper is all you'll find.
The film fails, in my estimation because it lacks any chemistry between the characters. There is no intensity, no dialog and no attraction to speak of. Nothing relationally seems real in this film. That would be fine if it contained actual and suspense to keep you going, but it fails there too. In fact, the Coen's try to rely on humor to keep you interested. Humor which, though occasionally seems helpful, is ultimately all that is left.
I wish I had more encouraging news on this film. It is definitely not the best movie to see in this season. Both "127 Hours" and "Fighter" are much more worthy of your money, in my opinion.
Amazon DVD Link: http://amzn.to/nx8fdR
Review by Kim Gentes.